Controversy over two taking same name, roll number, rank in UPSC exam – Who is the right person?

Indore: Recently the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) released the result of Civil Services Exam 2022. Candidates who faced this exam were interested to know the result. It includes two candidates from the state of Madhya Pradesh. Controversy arose that they both had the same first name, same roll number and same rank.

Both of them are shocked to know this detail. One of them is 23-year-old Ayesha Fatima from Dewas district of Madhya Pradesh. Another is 26-year-old Ayesha Makrani from Alirajpur district of the same state. Both are ranked 184th. Both of them lodged a police complaint to prove that they were the original candidates. This was also brought to the notice of UPSC. Ayesha Makrani had done this by demanding justice. He studied very hard for this for about two years. On the other hand, Ayesha Fatima said that such confusion should not happen in the future and that she is ready to do whatever it takes to resolve this issue.

A scrutinization of the admit card of both of them revealed that there were some discrepancies in the admit card of Ayesha Makrani. For example, the date for his personality test is mentioned as April 25, 2023. It also mentions that day is Thursday. But this year, April 25 falls on a Tuesday. That’s what Ayesha Fatima’s admit card mentions as Tuesday. Similarly, it has been revealed that there is a clear watermark on Ayesha Fatima’s admission ticket. But Ayesha Makrani’s admit card did not have it. It seems to be just a print out.

UPSC Description: UPSC exam has three stages. It includes Prelims, Mains and Personality Test. It is a very tough exam in India.

The UPSC has clarified that 2 persons falsely claimed that they were finally recommended by the Union Staff Selection Commission (UPSC) for the civil services examination as opposed to the 2 candidates who were honestly recommended. Both the claims of these two persons are false. They have forged documents in favor of their rights.

UPSC practice is robust and there is no margin for error. There is no possibility of mistakes like they say. An explanation is given that the claims of two bogus candidates are false.

Ayesha Makrani d/b. The valid registration number of Salimuddin Makrani is 7805064. He not only did not pass the initial level examination held on 5th June 2022 but also failed to proceed to the next level examination. In contrast, Ayesha Fatima D/P, whose registration number is 7811744. Naseeruddin is a true selector. He got 184th rank in Civil Services Exam 2022 and has been nominated by UPSC.

Similarly, Tushar T/P. Brij Mohan with registration number 2208860 also failed to pass the primary level examination and could not proceed to the next stage. In contrast Tushar Kumar d/b from Bihar bearing registration number 1521306. Ashwini Kumar Singh Actual Tester has got 44th rank and recommended by UPSC.

Many media channels and social media pages have irresponsibly published false information without any verification. UPSC is expected to verify the authenticity of such news while publishing it. According to the UPSC examination rules, both the candidates are guilty of providing false information and will be subject to legal disciplinary action for their fraudulent activities.